Grabbing Woman’s Breast Not Rape, Says Allahabad High Court
Allahabad HC's controversial rulings in rape cases—one denying 'attempt to rape' for assault on a minor, another blaming a victim—spark nationwide outrage.
India is seeing a sharp rise in rape cases, with over 31,677 reported in 2021 alone—about 86 every day. Experts fear the actual numbers could be higher, as many cases go unreported.
Recently, two controversial rulings by the Allahabad High Court have drawn heavy criticism.
Case 1: Minor’s Assault Not Called "Attempt to Rape"
In March 2025, Justice Ram Manohar Narayan Mishra ruled that two men who grabbed an 11-year-old girl’s breasts, loosened her clothes, and tried to drag her away did not commit an "attempt to rape." The court said their actions were only "preparation," not an actual attempt. Instead, they will be tried for assault and under POCSO laws.
After backlash, the High Court decided to review the order.
Case 2: Victim "Herself Responsible," Says Court
In another case, the court granted bail to a rape accused, saying the victim—a drunk MA student—"invited trouble" by being out late at night. The judge said she was mature enough to understand her actions.
Lawyers argue that under Indian law, if a woman is too drunk to consent, it is still rape.
Public and Legal Outrage
Politicians and lawyers have slammed these judgements. Shiv Sena MP Priyanka Chaturvedi tweeted, "Allahabad High Court seriously needs better judges." Former judges also expressed shock.
The rulings have raised concerns about how courts handle rape cases, especially when victims are blamed instead of offenders.
